Attention Protestants! This is your problem too. Church is church and all religions are the same to those who do not partake. Indeed, the scandals of the Catholic Church in recent months have reinforced the suspicion and skepticism that most religion is really a good ole boys club. In many cases it seems fair to assume that the higher up in the religious totem pole your face is placed, the more likely you are to escape the consequences. The un-churched consensus leans toward a disgusted delight like a teenager who digs up a dusty, F riddled report card of an overbearing parent. Who you were is who you are and groups are homogenous are two main presumptions that support the argument for rejecting religion on the basis for one congregant or leader’s failings.

Who you were is who you are
The crux of the Christian faith is change via forgiveness. A hypocritical church would be one that forgives sinners yet won’t forgive the saved. Yet, to the outsider, the rehabilitation process looks more like a pile of dirt lurking from beneath a rug rather than a situation that has been handled with a level of privacy equivalent to the crime committed. Historically, church leadership that was more politically motivated, would assume a standard of harsh repudiation involving a black and white standard of punishment and shunning for those humans who fell short of the divine order while at the same time elevating corrupt leaders due to their government influence and family ties. All it would take is for one priest, pastor or evangelist to be improperly reprimanded and the entire system loses its fidelity in the eyes of both the congregation and the world at large. As this has historically happened many times over, religion has lost credibility.
As human beings we desire repudiation. When something goes poorly, someone must suffer. It’s this natural response that encourages protesters and vigilantes to rebel when punishment seems unbalanced. Our instincts combined with experience tell us that people never change which creates the above mentioned suspicion and skepticism. In reality, religion is like any diet, exercise routine, substance recovery or marriage because it’s a commitment to a lifestyle change. your entire disposition won’t go away…ever. The person that you were pre-conversion is just trying with heavenly help to commit himself to a line of morality. It’s unfair to assume that all lusts and weaknesses will dissipate merely because the person has decided to change.
Groups are homogenous
People want to be treated as special snowflakes yet, habitually impose generalizations on those around them. Whether this is an evolutionary survival skill or a psychological means of coping with the unfamiliar does not matter so much as recognizing the fallacy that groups are homogenous. Sit in on one board meeting, one family dinner or one rousing locker room cheer as an outsider and you will feel like the members are both symbiotic and in agreement. Join said board meeting, family dinner or locker room cheer as a member and the subtext will become clearer. The tensions, the disappointment and betrayal glimmer from the knowledge of past experiences and suddenly you realize that the group, while they share a bond of necessity, is functioning in some way for a greater purpose. Whether that purpose is evil or good, is not proven by the sincerity of the members. People can be sincere and entirely wrong. People can be insincere and still serve a good purpose.
Part of becoming a balanced and developed person is understanding that you do not understand everything. Unfortunately, people can be distracted (as they should) by the loud and embarrassing individuals that are the exception. People are distracted by the evil member, improperly disciplined with regards to the public offense of their crime. We should all learn a lesson from the situation in the Catholic Church. Public crimes (such as those involving minors, violations of civil laws, and violations of church statutes) should be publicly explained. One can assume that offensives priests are relieved of positions involving minors, are demoted and secluded. However, the Catholic church would have been wise to let the public know (in minimal detail) how the situation was handled rather than leaving the un-churched to assume that nothing was done.
When nasty things happen in religious setting people react in many ways. Some disgustedly revoke all affiliation. Some are shaken in their previous beliefs. Others see the stumbling of another as a chance for a beautiful extension of grace and mercy.
How do religious scandals affect your view of religion?